2386 Shares

Did anyone else think My Sister's Keeper was horrible?

Did anyone else think My Sister's Keeper was horrible? Topic: The sisters keeper movie
June 16, 2019 / By Gwenneth
Question: I disliked the book to begin with, it wasn't really my cup of tea, but I thought the whole thing was wrong. They cut out Julia, Changed Zanne to Kelly (Who I personally thought was slutty and having a love affair with Jesse in the movie). And they had Kate die, not Anna. I felt it like was hard to fellow, very confusing. I don't think it represented the book properly. I still cried wicked hard though. Also, Jesse didn't lite anything on fire, he wasn't his drunk "bad boy" self. so disappointing.
Best Answer

Best Answers: Did anyone else think My Sister's Keeper was horrible?

Dindraine Dindraine | 1 day ago
As soon as the movie started i right off hated Jesse he was to close he was supposed to be distant and I kept waiting for julia. Also they should have added more dog jokes since that was the light humorous part of the book you know somewhere in the movie to make you smile "I'm a recovering alcholic and the dog keep me away from booze" sorry if its misquoted. Also the sister kelly (ugh) mainly tried to help with money not deeds. Overall the movie would have been great with a different title.. The movie seemed to revolve around the sick child its seemed to me like the movie was pleading for an oscar by using kate.
👍 170 | 👎 1
Did you like the answer? Did anyone else think My Sister's Keeper was horrible? Share with your friends

We found more questions related to the topic: The sisters keeper movie


Dindraine Originally Answered: Did anyone else think My Sister's Keeper was horrible?
As soon as the movie started i right off hated Jesse he was to close he was supposed to be distant and I kept waiting for julia. Also they should have added more dog jokes since that was the light humorous part of the book you know somewhere in the movie to make you smile "I'm a recovering alcholic and the dog keep me away from booze" sorry if its misquoted. Also the sister kelly (ugh) mainly tried to help with money not deeds. Overall the movie would have been great with a different title.. The movie seemed to revolve around the sick child its seemed to me like the movie was pleading for an oscar by using kate.
Dindraine Originally Answered: Did anyone else think My Sister's Keeper was horrible?
I loved the book and the movie was great! I thought it did a great job up until the ending was changed... that upset me, but i went in there already knowing it was changed so i was prepared. I still liked it, but it would have been better if the ending hadn't been changed. i def dont think it was horrible....jesse - we really didn't get to see all of him

Carine Carine
I loved the book and the movie was great! I thought it did a great job up until the ending was changed... that upset me, but i went in there already knowing it was changed so i was prepared. I still liked it, but it would have been better if the ending hadn't been changed. i def dont think it was horrible....jesse - we really didn't get to see all of him
👍 70 | 👎 -6

Carine Originally Answered: My Sister's Keeper. What did you think about the movie? **Spolier Alert**?
I really liked the movie! But I loved the book! In my mind, after seeing the film its like its two different stories?! I really like each of them but as different things as the changes made in the movie completely changed the whole story for me. Its like A Walk to Remember. I love the book and liked the movie but dont even think of them as the same storY!
Carine Originally Answered: My Sister's Keeper. What did you think about the movie? **Spolier Alert**?
I've read the book, but I haven't seen the movie. It isn't out where I live, yet, it comes out very soon though, I think. That's really annoying that they change a lot - I'll have to wait and see what I think, I guess. But Jesse being a trouble maker, and Campbell's story make up the book! That's what makes Jodi Picoult...Jodi Picoult. And they killed Kate? That just doesn't sound right. Jodi changes her endings for a reason. I'm not sure I want to watch the movie so much, but I suppose I will.. And maybe they changed it because...well, that's how movie producers are. They change good stuff into...not so good stuff.

If you have your own answer to the question the sisters keeper movie, then you can write your own version, using the form below for an extended answer.